Toler Hall Named for Trailblazing Don

USF dedicated Burl A. Toler Hall in May, renaming Phelan Hall in honor of Burl Toler 52, MA 66, co-captain of USF’s famous 1951 football team.

The move came after students raised concerns about former San Francisco Mayor James D. Phelan (who graduated from USF in 1881, when it was called St. Ignatius College) and his public opposition to immigration, diversity, and inclusion — all aspects of USF’s Jesuit Catholic education, as well as its mission and values.

Perhaps the best team of its era, Toler’s 1951 football squad finished the season 9-0. They were invited to play in the Orange Bowl, but only on the condition that they leave behind their two African American players — Burl Toler and Ollie Matson. The team refused and stood on principle against the racism of the time. The story was later broadcast on ESPN.

Nine players on the team were drafted by the NFL, Toler by the Chicago Cardinals. A knee injury ended his playing career, but he went on to become the first African American NFL referee and first African American official for any professional sport in the country.

In 1968, he became the first African American secondary school principal in San Francisco at Benjamin Franklin Middle School, which was later renamed Burl Toler Campus.

Toler was a USF alumnus of the year, a former USF trustee, and a member of the Bay Area Sports Hall of Fame. He died in 2009.

“This dedication means that future generations of Dons will learn Burl A. Toler Sr.’s name and his life story, and that his legacy will live on in the heart of our campus, indeed in the heart of the city where his many contributions have changed lives and made history,” said USF President Paul J. Fitzgerald, S.J.